Ask a Question on Bonjour Paris

Cross-Cultural Relationships – Playing with Fire?

By Karen Fawcett

Karen FawcettIt's June and based on the questions in Bonjour Paris's in-box, love must be in the air. Or, at the very least, like—okay, lust. There are so many e-mails that begin, "I've met someone who lives in France (or remplissez le blanc) and am considering..."

Perhaps it's because people are more mobile and even though air travel may not be glamorous or pleasant, it's easy enough to fly wherever you want for the person you want than ever before. And with the advent of Internet and email, it's simply easier to maintain long-distance relationships.

And that's only the beginning. Anyone can instant message, Skype and spend as much time (at least) communicating with someone else as if you were in the same city. The main impediment to whether or not you should pick up the phone is the time difference. I don't care how much you love speaking, not everyone feels like talking at three in the morning.

Some conjecture that on-line dating has opened up a whole new world. People who would never have "met" twenty years ago are striking up cyber relationships that may develop into something substantially more.

Can two people from different countries see eye to eye and agree on little things such as where to live, how to raise children, who's responsible for doing what and how? Factor in religious and political differences and you're asking for double (a conservative estimate) trouble. If you don't speak the same language, a lot gets lost in translation.

Will these relationships work? For some people yes—and for others, forget it. Unless they've been raised with the same set of values and references, cross-cultural relationships are too much of a stretch.

Some people are truly better off marrying someone from their community and (with luck) living happily ever after. The fact that fifty percent of marriages in the U.S. end in divorce seems to be lost on a lot of people. Marriage, or just getting together with reasonable seriousness, is, well, a serious matter. And who remembers the quaint thought that it's 'til death do us part?

The divorce rate is lower in France, which doesn't mean that people are necessarily more content. But, because France is a nominally Catholic country (all right, Catholicism ceased to be the state religion a century ago, and attendance at mass is on the slim side most Sundays), perhaps people are less likely to divorce for the sake of the children or their status within the community. And many couples opt not to marry for all kinds of reasons—including being able to establish a civil relationship, which is more common among heterosexual couples than homosexual ones.

But what's different now and interesting to me (and perhaps this is due to the somewhat older demographics of our readers) is that many of these emails are coming from Baby Boomers. We're the post-WW II generation of people who are (possibly) easing into retirement and many are "empty-nesters."

There's a good chance you like to travel if you're reading this site. So what about falling in love or like or lust and changing your lifestyle? Are people more willing to take a chance and move to another country? There are certainly a lot of reasons not to. But as I reminded someone who was chastising me for living in Paris because my grandchildren are in Washington, DC, I reminded them that the commute is an hour longer than if I were living in California.

Many of my American friends in Paris came to France for their college junior year abroad. So many of them stayed, married and have become more French than the French. Have their marriages worked? Not each and every one—but I am surprised how many have and how many of their children speak English with very French accents.

So much in relationships has to do with expectations and the ability to compromise. Can you be flexible in the way you approach life? Are you able to give the other person space to do what he or she needs to do—most especially when it comes to dealing with family who may live on the other side of the world? Are you capable of doing with someone from another country what is hard enough to do with someone from your own?

Real life situations cross us up, and unless you're a take-charge type, you may need to assert yourself. I was just speaking with someone who commented that even though he's 50 percent Italian and 50 percent American, he and his Italian wife don't understand one another all of the time. Duh—who does?

When I questioned a friend who's a therapist and does mediation training and conflict resolution, his first comment was that men and women tend to speak in different languages, and people (no matter their sexual orientation) get out of synch. And yes, there are some real negatives to being involved with someone from a different culture. On the other hand, there can be real pluses. Some people thrive in different cultures and may turn out to be more interesting than if they'd never left home. I like to think that's my case.

What's the best way to approach cross-cultural relationships? I have no idea. Only you and your other can have a clue. Try to figure it out, but look at the person, not the scenery, not the material. So what if he or she has the most spectacular apartment in Paris? You don't make love—or even like or lust—to an apartment. On the other hand, if you feel right together, where you live, isn't the be-all to end all—and there are worse places than France.

© Paris New Media, LLC

Karen@BonjourParis.com

If you're coming to France (or for that matter anywhere) you can reserve your hotel here. To rent a car, Bonjour Paris recommends Auto Europe.

Please register HERE if you need a free Bonjour Paris user name and password and post comments. I suspect there will be more than a few.

Print

COMMENTS

  • Howard Dinin

    Parisian Lover 14 Comments
    Napoleon Let us not forget, as has been noted elsewhere, that the laws of France are based on the Napoleonic Code (as opposed to British Common Law, as in preponderance of the U.S.of A.). This determines not only the strangeness and, to us, peculiarity of the laws governing the purchase and sale (and ownership) of real property. It also has a profound impact on the outcome of the dissolution of a conjugal relationship sanctioned in law, i.e., a marriage. My brush with this, a mere brush that left no permanent damage, concerned our purchase of property in France—as you discuss elsewhere—as foreign nationals. Given the laws, my late wife and I were, unfortunately, married in the eyes of the French government. Fortunately, at least for us, we had no issue... children, and the (again, to us) Byzantine laws designed to protect their interests according to social and cultural custom that dates back, in some instances, to feudal times. I suspect, without knowing at all, that many French marriages persist if there are children, because the dissolution of a union, and the division of property, very strictly defined in Napoleonic terms, presents a very sticky wicket, especially for children and potential beneficiaries. It would pay, I surmise, if one is to venture into a union with a citizen of another country, especially France, to follow Karen's advice re buying and selling real property, and that is, get a good lawyer, and sew up the differences in one's expectations of the legal ramifications of forming a union (with the always submerged potentiality of surviving its dissolution) with a pre-nuptial agreement, that takes into account both French Law and, say, U.S. law. With children, my late wife and I would have had to form a legal partnership (a unique and wonderful Italian/French invention with the charming name of "tontine") so that the survivor and the survivor alone would inherit the other portion of the property. My instincts tell me it gets even more complicated when each party to a marriage reflects not only a unique cultural heritage vis a vis the other, but also claims a different citizenship. But I could be wrong...
  • Well Said I really agree with what is written here. I have been married twice -- my first marriage was to a Chinese man as I lived and worked in PR China. My second marriage was to an American. I cannot pin that ending on cross-cultural issues, but can attest to just how hard marriage is with someone from one's own culture, too. I am now in a third serious relationship with an American man who is a long-time resident of Paris. I'm making darn sure that we are fully compatible before diving into marriage a third time! :)

    I have to agree with everything that has been written here about just how hard it is to be married, and how doing so cross-culturally presents even more challenges than one can imagine. It's also hard to be clear-thinking when you are in love. And not to sound like an old, cranky person, but marriage statistics are not great for young people who marry (under 30), in this or any other culture, much less an intercultural marriage.

    I wish I could go back and have a long chat with my young, idealistic self and give myself the advice to be very cautious and serious about intercultural marriage. I jumped in, idealistically thinking, "How hard can it be?" and was so hopeful that all would go well. I know that every individual is different, and like you write, there are some intercultural couples who will make it work, and make it work well, but I know more couples that struggle than are happy in a cross-cultural marriage. I really want to echo your final paragraph and what it has to say! Would that I could have read this 20 years ago, and been a wiser person in regards to my own situation.

    I am very grateful that my cross-cultural marriage brought us a beautiful son, and I am so glad he exists, but his existence came at a high price. A price I wish I would have been more thoughtful about with such wise counsel as you give here.

    Kudos for addressing this topic on Bonjour Paris!

POST A COMMENT

Please fill in all fields and then click Submit.
Once submitted, your comment will be sent for approval by one of our editors.

  • captcha

Premium Membership

Bonjour Paris is the Guide to Paris written by the top insiders in Paris. Join now and uncover all the secrets most American tourists will NEVER discover about Paris.